=====
great colors 
=====
I would have scored higher, but the primary element of the scene - the ship -
was done by someone else.

=====

the only god thing was the enterprise, and you didn't make it!

=====
The ships seems to just be hanging. The landscape is a bit awkward.


=====

the planets are too close together, and thus look unrealistic
=====
Not much raytracing in this picture...

=====
Is the terrain a Mandelbrot set?
=====
The engines could use more glow.

=====
Overly busy, in my opinion.


=====
I like the water and the background.
=====
Very nice background (it's almost cheating to use PhotoPaint for the background
though).


=====
This is a ray-tracing competition and unless I'm way wrong Vista is NOT a 
ray-tracing program. Nice image, but not ray-traced.