=====
Great clouds and sunset - but whats the blue thing under the X-wing ?

=====
No description of how picture was created.. Picture gave impression of 
over use of image maps.

=====
The background didn't even come close to fitting with the picture.


=====
The spacecraft is well done, but does not reflect the rising sun light source
used 
as a background.

=====
The ship's texture is dull

=====
One of the best looking sunlit skies I've ever seen.

=====
Your backdrop is wrong.  No, really wrong.


=====
It looks too clean, how about some swamp stains...

=====
This looks in many ways like a "show-off" of the sky texture, which in
absence of any description to the contrary, I believe to be bitmap in the
background.  Artistically, the photorealism of the sky makes the X-Wing model
look very out of place and artificial by comparison.  Nice composition,
though.  If the artist created the X-Wing model himself, or if the sky is
other than a projected bitmap, then my technical vote would come up somewhat,
but without a description in the text, I can't tell.  Consistency question:
This X-Wing is in flight.  So where's the astrogation droid?

=====
Needs less plastic textures.

=====
Nice spaceship, though the beackground doesn't 'emit' the light.., so the effect
of 
"dawning" light is wasted...


=====
The horizon's too close!

=====
The detail on the background and the ship don't seem to quite match on this
one...

=====
 Beautiful sunset! But, I loose the mood when I look at the ship. Work on
detail.

=====
"Oh, look, honey, another Star Wars stock model against a bitmapped
background!"  "Quel original!"  Nice choice of background, anyway.


=====
what texture???
Notable for textures