===== Wot no comments? WIthout any b/g info, one cannot judge technical merit. I can't believe we had yet another loads of Xwings too. This is my least favourite of all the images I've seen so far, as it shows so little imagination. ===== HOW DARE YOU CALL THAT AN X-WING!!!!!!!! HEATHEN!!!!! ===== Well at least tell us what you used! ===== It might not have been a particularly faithful XWing, but it looked great. ===== What renderer did you use? my guess is povray but i could be wrong ===== Nice looking craft. Wings could have used a little finesse. ===== the text file is really short 8( ===== i like the original better ===== What's that second ship shooting at? ===== I like the laser beams and especially the fact that you modeled the ships yourself. The sharp specular reflections on the ships make them look like their hung in front of a painting, however. ===== A little more time in the modeller would improve your image by a few orders of magnitude ===== It's nice to see X-Wings that aren't taken straight from George Lusas' blueprints, but rather a pretty good impression. ===== I gave you low marks because your comments file is patheticly small. Please give more info next time. ===== Clean simple modelling of craft ... What happened to the planet? It looks _deflated_ and parts are flying off ... ===== X-WIngs are boring ! No Originality ! ===== This one is the definition of a "stinker." ===== I guess you missed the "Science Fiction" deadline, huh? The ships look like toys. Try adding some much needed texture, especially when close up. ===== Oh, man... this is why some people don't want to have kids. ===== The ships look like funny shaped balloons. ===== picture dark lacks details ===== Great nebula effect ===== More space stuff (yes, I AM tired off it) ===== Missed the SF round, eh? I suppose you did these models yourself? Can't tell (and points off) because of no explanation. Overall, fairly boring scene. Planet in background is not too bad, I guess.