=====
From jminner@sc.rr.com:
good concept, but i've seen this type of piece before.  the model is very good.

=====
From ph.gibone@wanadoo.fr:
Funny, could be a nice start for a post-atomic science fiction movie. Dunes are great

=====
From rgow@lanset.com:
Nice submarine. Seems incomplete though, more to the image is needed.

=====
From szabocom@zappmobile.ro:
Nice submarine modelling. I like the model, but I think the desert looks very unnatural. I think you should use a better sky, and try bump-mapping the sand.
=====
From thatsalloneword@msn.com:

Nice concept, nice submarine.
=====
From pmccombs@xmission.com:
Well done.

=====
From marlo.steed@uleth.ca:
This is a stunning image.  I like the concept.  The dunes look good and the sub looks good bu perhaps overlly glossy.  The sand could have used a hint of texture.  Still a nice aesthetically pleasing image.
=====
From kingofmycastle@gmx.net:
I like the brilliance of the pic. The texturing
is nice as well.
But I think it could look more hot. It looks
more like 20° Celsius than 45° or more.


=====
From kevinq2000@yahoo.com:
Weird =/= Surrealism.  Nice Type VII, though.

=====
From hildurka@simnet.is:

The model looks great, but the surroundings might need some more work. Especially the sand. It looks too clean.


=====
From file:
A nice idea, but perhaps the submarine could have been a little more aged perhaps? Maybe a bit of slime if it had just come out of the sea, or if it had been there a long time make it rusty and have a few holes in the hull. I don't know if it was how you intended it - but the boat seems more of a shiny new toy. Hey! - toy boat in a sandpit - real boat in a desert - I feel an idea coming on...


=====
From file:
Nice details on the boat, really sharp clean image. You should add some texturing to the sand and sky, and maybe some fog to simulate flying sand.
Notable for composition


=====
From file:
for MentalRay and Maya I'd expect a better looking sand...