=====
From helene.dumur@free.fr:
It's not a ray-tracing picture !

=====
From ph.gibone@wanadoo.fr:
I don't like the colours, I don't get the idea behind the scene, but I do feel something looking at it

=====
From rgow@lanset.com:
Looks like a rules violation to me. Last time I checked neither illustrator or photopaint were 3d renderers.

=====
From szabocom@zappmobile.ro:
Nice Illustrator and photoshop paint. But this is a RAYTRACING competition. Sorry, I can't give you points for this.
=====
From douge@nls.net:
I would have rated this as one of the top entries had it been done with a renderer.  It definitely qualifies as surreal, and to have been done by hand with Illustrator and Photoshop shows some real talent as well.  

=====
From kingofmycastle@gmx.net:
This is the first picture I saw in this competition
which is pseudo 3D.

=====
From hildurka@simnet.is:
I´m sorry, I like your image very much, and your concept is really fantastic! But this contest is only for 3D programs and as far as I know neither Illustrator or Paint are 3D rendering programs. You might want to read the rules for entering. But your image really is outstanding!

=====
From 25ct@lineone.net:
Trippy, but great use of colour in this image.