=====
From skipt1@aol.com:
A good scene and concept, but the modeling and texturing need much work.  The actual sword itself is far too yellow to be a realistic metal or gold finish.  However, it is a dramatic presentation.
=====
From shevlin@uic.edu:
The link to the topic is a bit weak.  The lighting seems a little odd, and the water and waterfalls could use a little work.  The yellow texture on the sword isn't very convincing and it appears to have some strange reflections near the waterline.



=====
From hildurka@simnet.is:

Nice concept and the composition is quite good. But you have to use different maps for your heightfields, using images of rocks or trees usually doesn´t do the trick. 
=====
From renebui@aol.com:
The water doesn't work for me but trees are great.

=====
From sshelby@shelbyvision.com:
Mostly well done. The waterfalls could be improved, but 
don't ask me how.


=====
From file:
Wow!
Notable for composition, originality, modelling, lighting, textures