÷ƒ’À;è TeX output 1995.10.03:1353‹ÿÿÿÿ l� ý» '� þ&�‘DèóDÓítG®G®cmr17¹Build–7tpro�sŽof“tree“for“Natural“Deduction,“Sequen�ŒqtŽŸ�’½Calculus,‘7tetc.ŽŸ�����’ÍdYóX«Q cmr12ºP•¬raul‘ê¨T‘ÿVa“ylorŽŽ¤��’¥¼tDepartmen�¬rt–ê¨of“Computing,ŽŽ¡��’¿Ä5Imp�SŽerial‘ê¨College,ŽŽ¡��’½RLondon–ê¨SW7“2BZŽŽ¡��’©'ö+44–ê¨71“589“5111“ó!›»ˆ@ cmti12Ìext‘ìº5057ŽŽ¡��’·2ó߆µT cmtt12ÉŽŽŽŽŽŸ]ˆ‹�’‰ãºOctob�SŽer–ê¨3,“1995ŽŸ"Ô†�‘NóKñ`y cmr10²Using–UUmš¸ãy“Pro�Gof“T‘ÿ*ªree“macros,“y˜ou“can“pro�GduceŽŸM‰A���Ÿ+0��¤îÇ ��¡�‘?ó-o´‹Ç cmr9Ø[(ó/©±�Ê cmsy9Ú9ó.5ùž" cmmi9Ùy•Rª:��‘ŠªØ(Ž��‘#Œ(Ž‘¼nÚ9Ùn:x�Ÿÿÿó;Îcmmi6¿nŽ‘¯ýØ=‘‘ÆÙy�“Ø)ŽŽ‘7?éÚ^‘8Ùq“y�“Ø)ŽŽ‘Lg>)–8Ú^“Ø(Ú8Ùw•>:��‘ŠªØ(Ž��‘#Œ(Ž‘¼nÚ9Ùn:x�Ÿÿÿ¿nŽ‘¯ýØ=‘‘ÆÙw�“Ø)ŽŽ‘9Á±Ú)‘‘ÆÙpw�“Ø)ŽŽ‘T°$)]�Ÿÿÿ¿ ŽŽ¤œp��‘?Ÿþ„€ßcç�‘ÆgŸÿÿÚ^Ž‘ñŸÿÿØ1ÚEŽŽ¡��’‚3;9Ùy•Rª:��‘ŠªØ(Ž��‘#Œ(Ž‘¼nÚ9Ùn:x�Ÿÿÿ¿nŽ‘¯ýØ=‘‘ÆÙy�“Ø)ŽŽ‘7?éÚ^‘8Ùq“y�“Ø)ŽŽŽŽŽ�¡��¡��¡��¡��¡�‘Jb*[(Ú9Ùy•Rª:��‘ŠªØ(Ž��‘#Œ(Ž‘¼nÚ9Ùn:x�Ÿÿÿ¿nŽ‘¯ýØ=‘‘ÆÙy�“Ø)ŽŽ‘7?éÚ^‘8Ùq“y�“Ø)ŽŽ‘Lg>)–8Ú^“Ø(Ú8Ùw•>:��‘ŠªØ(Ž��‘#Œ(Ž‘¼nÚ9Ùn:x�Ÿÿÿ¿nŽ‘¯ýØ=‘‘ÆÙw�“Ø)ŽŽ‘9Á±Ú)‘‘ÆÙpw�“Ø)ŽŽ‘T°$)]�Ÿÿÿ¿ ŽŽ¤œp��‘Jb*Ÿþ„€ßcç�‘ÆgŸÿÿÚ^Ž‘ñŸÿÿØ2ÚEŽŽ¡��’ÄqÕ8Ùw•>:��‘ŠªØ(Ž��‘#Œ(Ž‘¼nÚ9Ùn:x�Ÿÿÿ¿nŽ‘¯ýØ=‘‘ÆÙw�“Ø)ŽŽ‘9Á±Ú)‘‘ÆÙpw�“Ø)ŽŽŽŽŽŽ¤œp��’ÄqÕŸþ„€cD‘‘ÆgŸÿÿÚ8EŽŽ¡��’Ò|Ø(Ú9Ùn:x�Ÿÿÿ¿nŽ‘¯ýØ=–‘ÆÙy�RªØ)“Ú)“ÙpyŽŽŽ�¡�’FCìØ[(Ú9Ùn:x�Ÿÿÿ¿nŽ‘¯ýØ=‘‘ÆÙyšRªØ)–8Ú^“Ùq˜y˜Ø]�Ÿ¿ ŽŽ¤œp��’FCìŸþ„€MÍw�‘ÆgŸÿÿÚ^Ž‘ñŸÿÿØ1ÚEŽŽ¡��’X¼w9Ùn:x�Ÿÿÿ¿nŽ‘¯ýØ=‘‘ÆÙyŽŽŽŽ¤œp��’Ò|Ÿþ„€¯€\�‘ÆgŸÿÿÚ)Ž‘ cŸÿÿEŽŽ¡��’WàÙpyŽŽŽ’’ï@Ø[(Ú9Ùn:x�Ÿÿÿ¿nŽ‘¯ýØ=‘‘ÆÙyšRªØ)–8Ú^“Ùq˜y˜Ø]�Ÿ¿ ŽŽ¤œp��’WàŸþ„€‰¦×�‘ÆgŸÿÿÚ^Ž‘ñŸÿÿIŽŽ¡��’l”«Ùpy‘`âÚ^–8Ø((Ú9Ùn:x�Ÿÿÿ¿nŽ‘¯ýØ=‘‘ÆÙyšRªØ)“Ú^“Ùq˜y˜Ø)ŽŽŽŽ¤œp��’c®Ÿþ„€q±;‘ÆgŸÿÿÚ9IŽŽ¡��’c®9Ùz•c�:pz‘qÅÚ^��‘8Ø(Ž��‘§(Ž��‘ ?ü(Ž‘ ØÞÚ9Ùn:x�Ÿÿÿ¿nŽ‘¯ýØ=‘‘ÆÙz�“Ø)ŽŽ‘;,ZÚ^‘8Ùq�Rªz�“Ø)ŽŽ�‘P#°)ŽŽŽŽŽŽ¤œp��’‚3;Ÿþ„€RŽ®‘ÆgŸÿÿÚ9E�Ÿ¿ ŽŽŽ¡��’ò¡õÚ9Ùz•c�:pz‘qÅÚ^��‘8Ø(Ž��‘§(Ž��‘ ?ü(Ž‘ ØÞÚ9Ùn:x�Ÿÿÿ¿nŽ‘¯ýØ=‘‘ÆÙz�“Ø)ŽŽ‘;,ZÚ^‘8Ùq�Rªz�“Ø)ŽŽ�‘P#°)ŽŽŽŽŽŽ¤œp��‘}`ÿŸþ„€\3&�‘ÆgŸÿÿÚ)Ž‘ cŸÿÿI�Ÿÿÿ¿ ŽŽŽ¡��‘}`ÿØ(Ú9Ùy•Rª:��‘ŠªØ(Ž��‘#Œ(Ž‘¼nÚ9Ùn:x�Ÿÿÿ¿nŽ‘¯ýØ=‘‘ÆÙy�“Ø)ŽŽ‘7?éÚ^‘8Ùq“y�“Ø)ŽŽ‘Lg>)–8Ú^“Ø(Ú8Ùw•>:��‘ŠªØ(Ž��‘#Œ(Ž‘¼nÚ9Ùn:x�Ÿÿÿ¿nŽ‘¯ýØ=‘‘ÆÙw�“Ø)ŽŽ‘9Á±Ú)‘‘ÆÙpw�“Ø)ŽŽ‘T°$)–‘ÆÚ)“Ø(Ú9Ùzšc�:pz‘qÅÚ^��‘8Ø(Ž��‘§(Ž��‘ ?ü(Ž‘ ØÞÚ9Ùn:x�Ÿÿÿ¿nŽ‘¯ýØ=“Ùz�˜Ø)ŽŽ‘;,ZÚ^‘8Ùq�Rªz�˜Ø)ŽŽ�‘P#°)ŽŽ‘S¼’)ŽŽŽŽŽŸN A�‘BUU²using–UUthe“T�‘þU>Ÿ'EŽ›ãxX“or“L�Ÿýó5�‘üffóÙ“ Rcmr7±AŽŽ‘͉²T�‘þU>Ÿ'EŽ˜X“co�GdeŽŸj�‘?óBßê cmmi10µA‘ Bޤœp��’Ì€÷Ÿýæg„ÌÎ.$s�‘Ÿ™ó !",š cmsy10¸^Ž‘ ª®Ÿ™IŽŽ¡��’ßòõA–8à¸^“µBŽŽŽŽŽŸí��‘?²The–Íhš¸ãyp�Gotheses“ma˜y“themselv˜es“bšGe“pro˜of“trees“(enclosed“in“ëB\[��µ:–ª¨:“:ŽŽ‘ UOëB\]²)“and“theŽ¡�‘?purp�Gose–ç_of“the“macros“is“to“adjust“the“length“of“the“horizon�¸ãtal“\deduction"“line.ŽŽŸ�’é2ŽŽŒ‹ ¿ l� ý» '� ýü�‘?²When–ºthe“h�¸ãypšGotheses“are“pro˜of“trees,‘Ù)suitable“space“is“put“b˜et•¸ãw“een–ºthem,‘Ù)but“ofޤ �‘?course–ϯthis“mš¸ãust“b�Ge“supplied“b˜y“hand“for“simple“form˜ulae.‘E;The“ëB\thickness“²andŽ¡�‘?ëB\shiftright–Ò¿²commands“are,›òof“course,˜optional;‘sthey“apply“to“the“horizon�¸ãtalŽ¡�‘?line–ùRand“to“the“p�Gositioning“of“the“conclusion“relativ�¸ãe“to“it.‘]¿F‘ÿ*ªor“a“double“line,Ž¡�‘?use–UUëB\Justifies“²instead“of“ëB\justifies².Ž¡�‘NNotice–�Ùthe“o•¸ãv“erloading–�Ùof“the“ëB\[��µ:–ª¨:“:ŽŽ‘ UOëB\]²;‘the“outermost“prošGof“tree“m�¸ãust“b˜eŽ¡�‘?enclosed–öëwith“ëB\begin{prooftree}“²and“ëB\end{prooftree}“²or“ëB\prooftree“²andŽ¡�‘?ëB\endprooftree².Ž¡�‘NT‘ÿ*ªo–UUget“a“v�¸ãertical“string“of“dots“instead“of“the“pro�Gof“rule,“doŽ©�‘?ëB\[Ž¡�‘?[A]Ž¡�‘?\usingŽ¡�‘?\piŽ¡�‘?\proofdotseparation=1.2exŽ¡�‘?\proofdotnumber=4Ž¡�‘?\leadstoŽ¡�‘?BŽ¡�‘?\]ŽŸñ½�‘?²to–UUget�Ÿñc–�“[µA²]ŽŸ1À���‘xäŸøUX�ž£��¸ŽŽ¤*¨�ž£��ŽŽ¡�ž£��ŽŽ¡�ž£��ŽŽŽ‘@µŽŽŸ‡��‘ÑVBŽŽŽŽŸ1�‘N²All–M‡of“of“the“k•¸ãeyw“ords–M‡except“ëB\prooftree“²and“ëB\endprooftree“²are“optionalŽ¡�‘?and–êªmaš¸ãy“app�Gear“in“an˜y“order.‘1ÇThey“ma˜y“also“b�Ge“com˜bined“in“ëB\newcommand²s,Ž¡�‘?for‘UUexampleަ�‘?ëB\newcommand\Cut{\using\sf‘?ýcut\thickness.08em\justifies}ަ�‘?²with–UUthe“abbreviationަ�‘?ëB\[–?ýA“\vdash“B“\qquadŽ¡�‘N¿÷B–?ý\vdash“CŽ¡�‘Iú\CutŽ¡�‘N¿÷A–?ý\vdash“CŽ¡�‘?\]ަ�‘N\thickness–`²sp�Geci es“the“breadth“of“the“rule“in“anš¸ãy“units,‘¢Ãalthough“fon˜t-Ž¡�‘?relativš¸ãe–.ìunits“suc˜h“as“ex“or“em“are“preferable.‘þŒIt“ma˜y“optionally“b�Ge“follo˜w˜edŽ¡�‘?b�¸ãy–‹õ=.‘¨ëB\proofrulebreadth=.08em“²or“ëB\setlength\proofrulebreadth{.08em}Ž¡�‘?²ma�¸ãy–galso“b�Ge“used“either“in“place“of“ëB\thickness“²or“globally;‘¶vthe“default“is“0.04em.Ž¡�‘?ëB\proofdotseparation–ñвand“ëB\proofdotnumber“²con�¸ãtrol“the“size“of“the“string“ofŽ¡�‘?dots.Ž¡�‘NIf–’Ãpro�Gof“trees“and“form�¸ãulae“are“mixed,›¢some“explicit“spacing“is“needed,˜butŽ¡�‘?don't–Áƒput“anš¸ãything“to“the“left“of“the“left-most“(or“the“righ˜t“of“the“righ˜t-most)ŽŽŸ�’é3ŽŽŒ‹ª l� ý» '� ýü�‘?²h�¸ãyp�Gothesis,›zûor–@@put“it“in“braces,˜bšGecause“this“will“cause“the“inden�¸ãtation“to“b˜eޤ �‘?lost.Ž¡�‘NBy–ÌEdefault“the“conclusion“is“cenš¸ãtered“wrt“the“left-most“and“righ˜t-most“im-Ž¡�‘?mediate–5éh�¸ãypšGotheses“(not“their“pro˜ofs);‘¦2ëB\shiftright“²or“ëB\shiftleft“²mo•¸ãv“es‘5éitŽ¡�‘?relativ�¸ãe–Zèto“this“pšGosition.‘‚�(Not“sure“ab˜out“this“sp˜eci cation“or“ho�¸ãw“it“shouldŽ¡�‘?a ect–UUspreading“of“pro�Gof“tree.)ŽŽŸ�’é4ŽŽŒø:ƒ’À;èl˜óDý': cmti10óBßê cmmi10óKñ`y cmr10óÙ“ Rcmr7ùVßßßßß